How is this response different from the way you thought of him in beowulf. Grendels mother, monster of women, mourned her woe. And his mother now, gloomy and grim, would go that quest. When beowulf is explored from grendels point of view, it becomes apparent that the division between hero and villain lies in the eyes of the beholder. Grendels life prior to the story can be seen as tragic and cruel by most standards. The point of view from which the beowulf manuscript can be depicted is as a godlike narration, where the storyteller is aware of everything going on in the world as well as the past, present, and future of the story. This is my interpretation of grendels side of the story of the wonderful epic poem, beowulf. The beowulf legend retold from grendels point of view. This is the story of the battle between grendels mother and beowulf. List of translations and artistic depictions of beowulf. Not looking for a big thing, just a few ideas, i have started but i need direction you are looking at the battle between beowulf and grendel from beowulfs point of view. Upon reading beowulf, the reader discovers grendel as seen through the eyes of his terrified victims. For instance, by telling the story of hygelacs victory over the swedes largely from the. Although beowulf defeats grendel, the poem switches to the defeated monsters point of view to show us that beowulfs heroism has only caused further pain and suffering.
Grendel, the beowulf story is retold from grendels point of view in this novel by john gardner. The first night that beowulf is with the scyldings, grendel stomps up from the. For example, in the book beowulf grendel is seen as a monster and beowulf is seen as a hero. Point of view in grendel and beowulf essay 1242 words bartleby. Beowulf is not written in firstperson point of view and does not show the reader grendels perspective on events.
Point of view beowulf s point of view beowulf point of view was told in first person as well. Since this question asks about both the text of beowulf and grendel, options c and d must be eliminated immediately. Using grendel s perspective to tell at least part of the story of beowulf in more contemporary language allows the story to be seen in a new light not only in terms of the point of view but also brings it into the modern era. In john gardners novel grendel, it is clear that first person point of view does not provide richer reading experience, while in the epic poem beowulf, it is clear that third person point of view overrides biases with clear actions. The point of view from which the beowulf manuscript can be depicted is as a godlike. Beowulf highlights the heroic and positive world in which beowulf lives. Descended from the biblical cain, grendel is an outcast, doomed to wander the face of the earth. Since the story is from the outcasts point of view, its no surprise that the narrative oozes cynicism and manic dark humor. Point of view in grendel and beowulf essay graduateway.
By lineage, grendel is a member of cains clan, whom the creator had outlawed and condemned as outcasts. He revenges himself upon humans by terrorizing and occasionally devouring the warriors of the danish king hrothgar. Point of view in grendel and beowulf 1236 words 123. Check out the dragon, who takes on a tone that s a combo of professors binns the boring ghostly professor of history of magic at hogwarts and snape the. From the beginning, he has been an outcast of the world, for no greater crime than his existence. The book translated by burton raffel, beowulf, is written in third person. You have been asked to share your story with the natives of your land. As i reached for my next meal his arm moved and he came alive.
Her death is just one of the many false tales told about her. That first reference shows us that the dragon of gardners story is the same one beowulf will kill at the end of his life. Grendel as he is portrayed in grendel grendel grendel the australian animated film grendel, grendel, grendel, is based on john gardners the story, told from grendels point of view. The poet hints that behind grendels aggression against the danes lies loneliness and jealousy. The narrator wanted the audience to look at beowulf as the one who was going to defeat grendel and that was the reason for the narrator. Oct 23, 2012 while the epic, beowulf, is told from the point of view of beowulf and the danes, grendel, gives insight into his own side of the story. Beowulfgrendel fight from grendels point of view alefa. Gardners retelling, however, presents the story from the existentialist view of grendel. The theme is essentially an underlying meaning of a piece of literature. She has been biding her time, and plotting her revenge against the man that murdered her son. This point of view is formally known as third person omniscient. And its not only grendels voice that comes across this way. Whereas grendel elucidates on the miserable life that grendel is circumscribed to. The narrator also comments on the action, usually to draw out moral implications.
The oral tradition of the epic poem beowulf began around the eighth century. She, grendels mother, awakens to the faint sound and smell of the things known as men. The point of view of the book grendel allows the reader to see another side of grendel. Read the description of grendel from the epic poem beowulf. Beowulf is his ulimate adversary, the shining example of everything he hates.
A story told in one mothers pointofview she, grendels mother, awakens to the faint sound and smell of the things known as men. The beowulf story, in combination with a fictionalized 10th century arabic narrative of ahmad ibn fadlan created by the author michael crichton, was. The date of composition is a matter of contention among scholars. There were nights they took him to the arena to fight whatever beast they had captured on their last hunt. To get to the point, why dont we count his mother among the great germanic. Jan 21, 2011 beowulf grendels point of view january 21, 2011 filed under. Btell the story of grendels encounters with humans. I wasnt able to sleep because i could hear the damn people singing up in that thing they called the hall, which in my opinion was ugly as hell. Both beowulf and grendel aare epic poems written hundreds of years ago. She was doomed to dwell in the dreary waters, cold seacourses. Grendel, a novel by john gardner, gives us the classic story of the epic poem beowulf from the monster grendel s perspective. But just when beowulf seems to have narrowly avoided death, he must fight a second demon, grendels mother. Beowulf is not written in firstperson point of view and does not show the reader grendel s perspective on events. How does grendels telling of his own story affect your response to him.
The first manuscript of beowulf was written in old english and survived a fire in the scholar sir robert cottons home. I grabbed him up off of the floor swiftly and gnawed on his limp body. In beowulf, grendel is depicted as a horrible, murderous, and evil monster, but in grendel the reader can see that grendel is actually much different. That one sentence treatment of grendel suggests some unsustainable satire, valid for. Exiled to the swamplands outside the boundaries of human society, grendel is an outcast who seems to long to be reinstated. Jan 30, 2009 2 the battle with grendelfrom grendels point of view as you all know the battle between grendel and beowulf was epic, beowulf was an epic warrior with an extraordinary strength, and grendel was a horrible maneating monster that also had extraordinary strength. The narrator wanted the audience to look at beowulf as. An overview of the story beowulf from the point of grendels. John gardner published the novel grendel, a retelling of beowulf from grendels point of view.
The beowulf narrator s unusual use of voice and point of view is probably due to the fact that it is coming out of an oral storytelling tradition, as opposed to a written one. It is told through grendels mothers point of view, as she finds her son. Both beowulf and grendel aare epic poems written hundreds. You have just arrived back in scandinavia after defeating grendel. Gardners novel follows the story from grendels point of view as he. This article was most recently revised and updated by kathleen kuiper, senior editor. He portrayed the ridiculous hairy beast torn apart by poetry sympathetically, and walked him through the great concepts of western civilization, considering them from the outside with an existentialist edge. At this point, beowulf begins a rollercoaster ride of wild emotional ups and. Both novels are based on the idea of beowulf killing grendel. Grendel, a novel by john gardner, gives us the classic story of the epic poem beowulf from the monster grendels perspective.
Beowulf was originally a poem passed on through oral tradition. The film shows how the events werent his fault, and were mostly to blame on the greed and aggression of the humans. Point of view and the oral tradition in beowulf victoria j. This is the story of the battle between grendel s mother and beowulf. Beowulf retold from grendels mothers pointofview 123. For example, beowulf is written from an outsider s point of view. Beowulf retold from grendels mothers pointofview 123 help me. An overview of the story beowulf from the point of grendel. The unknown author uses symbolism, point of view, setting and the traits of each character to retell and epic legend based on the hero beowulf, revealing the major themes of loyalty, generosity and hospitality, revenge. Oct 05, 2010 you are looking at the battle between beowulf and grendel from beowulfs point of view. Beowulf fights and narrowly defeats grendel, aided by god and by his valiant decision to meet grendel in handtohand combat.
And it s not only grendel s voice that comes across this way. Consider the selection you just read from the perspectives of grendel, grendels mother, and the dragon. Point of view in grendel and beowulf essay on beowulf. The 20thcentury american writer john gardner told the story of beowulf from grendels point of view in grendel 1971. His name was hrothgar he was very powerful and he had a hall called herot that was the most awful place always so joyful and filled with loud noisy music people always sang and never stopped shouting and. Jan 22, 2008 the story of beowulf from grendels point of view. Seeing a story written from two different points of views not only helps you to understand the story better, but can also change the story dramatically. It is told through grendel s mother s point of view, as she finds her son limping halfdead back to her cave.
When the western mound to the left in the photo was excavated in 1874, the finds showed that a powerful man was buried in a large barrow, c. Grendel is a 1971 novel by american author john gardner. He follows a traditional norse hero pattern, fighting to the last of his strength, but ultimately coming up short. However, in the book grendel grendel is a misunderstood and kind creature. Since the story is from the outcast s point of view, it s no surprise that the narrative oozes cynicism and manic dark humor. Try to imagine this novel written from the third person point of view though still from the monsters side. How to survive writing your beowulf essay kibin blog.
I was so hungry, something inside of me told me to turn back, but i couldnt. When the poem switches to grendels point of view during his fight with beowulf, the reader understands that violence causes suffering and calls forth vengeance even when it is used against an unmistakably evil opponent. From the great early epic beowulf comes this original story, from the. But a close look at the story reveals the rarely told tale of grendel, who despite dishonor and pain still fights to right the wrongs done to him and his ancestors. She is filled with sadness just as any mother would be to find her son like that. What does first person narration add to gardners tale. The poems narrator has access to the interior thoughts and feelings of all the characters, even the dragon. Beowulf point of view was told in first person as well. Beowulf from the monsters viewpoint the new york times. This is in grendels point of view with his first battle and meeting with beowolf in the dinning hall. My personal interest was always in the monster grendel. I was sleeping in a cold night at my muddy and dark house under the warm lake. However, the two different points of view telling the story create vastly different novels.
Point of view and the oral tradition in beowulf victoria. In reading grendel and beowulf, one can findmany similarities in the way the events occur in the books, however becauseof contrasting points of view, the reader. Beowulf is an epic poem written hundreds of years ago. She, grendel s mother, awakens to the faint sound and smell of the things known as men. But just when beowulf seems to have narrowly avoided death, he must fight a second demon, grendel s mother. Behavior thats admired is the path to power among people everywhere ll. Grendels mother was a grieving monster, seeking revenge. The poem of beowulf is told, of course, from the point of view of the heroic humans, the geats and the danes. John gardners novel grendel 1971 is a retelling of the story of beowulf from grendels point of view.
Grendel, however, brings a different point of view of the world of beowulf. When the poem switches to grendels point of view during his fight with beowulf, the reader. Grendel point of view essays it was a dark night, a quiet night. She has been biding her time, and plotting her revenge again.
What is grendels point of view in the world of beowulf. Sure, grendel gives us his firstperson account of what its. I wasnt able to sleep because i couldnt take off of my mind the idea of. By the time the etens appear in the finnsburh story, we also know that beowulf y. Seeing a story written from two different points of views not only helps you to understand. Where grendel is portrayed mainly as a physical creature in the original work, here a glimpse into his psyche is offered. A story told in one mothers point of view she, grendels mother, awakens to the faint sound and smell of the things known as men. While grendel is not written in poetic verse as beowulf is, it still. In beowulf, grendel is viewed as the antagonist and the evil villain. This is in grendel s point of view with his first battle and meeting with beowolf in the dinning hall.
How would the story look if it were told from beowulfs point of view or grendels point of view. Beowulf grendels point of view january 21, 2011 filed under. Different perspectives in his 20th century novel grendel, writer john gardner tells the story of grendels attacks against the danes from the monsters point of view. Grendel, fictional character, a monstrous creature defeated by beowulf in the old english poem beowulf composed between 700 and 750 ce. Eadgils was buried at uppsala gamla uppsala, sweden according to snorri sturluson. What information would readers not understand if the poem was written through another type of narration. Grendel as he is portrayed in grendel grendel grendel.
Beowulf i was sleeping in a cold night at my muddy and dark house under the warm lake. Point of view in grendel and beowulf essay 1242 words. The unknown author uses symbolism, point of view, setting and the traits of each character to retell and epic legend based on the hero beowulf, revealing the major themes of loyalty, generosity and hospitality, revenge, envy, and reputation based on their role within the era. Beowulf is told from a thirdperson omniscient point of view. Once upon a time there was a very good king in a far away land, the king of the danes. The fact that gardner used grendel as the narrator in his story is very important. Point of view beowulfs point of view beowulf point of view was told in first person as well. I dont own beowulf ive actually never seen the movie, but last year, my teacher had us read one of the older beowulf stories and we had to write a story wh. Good and evil is one of the main conflicts in the poem beowulf. Gardner calls into question the heroism of beowulf, and offers a starkly different account of the events described in the epic poem. All that she had left in the cold and unforgivable world was her. Check out the dragon, who takes on a tone thats a combo of professors binns the boring ghostly professor of history of magic at hogwarts and snape the. Gardner completely changes the way the anglosaxon characters and societies are viewed. While the epic, beowulf, is told from the point of view of beowulf and the danes, grendel, gives insight into his own side of the story.
Point of view in grendel and beowulf 1236 words 123 help me. She has been sleeping down in her dark and dingy cave below the world that is known to men. On the other hand, one with a confident, hopeful, and positive attitude is an optimistic person. When beowulf is explored from grendels point of view, it becomes. I think grendels point of view of the world is a little skewed he has such a burning hatred for men that he murders and eats them, so he has to be a bit of a psycopath. The australian animated film grendel, grendel, grendel, is based on john gardner s the story, told from grendel s point of view. Also, in the novel, grendel is a thinking being, striving to find his place in the anglosaxon society. Beowulfgrendel fight from grendels point of view january 21, 2008. It is one of the most important works of old english literature. Tell the story of the battle from your beowulfs perspective. Grendelss point of view battle with beowolf, a beowulf. In the novel grendel, by john gardner, the dragon displays a nihilistic attitude after seeing the world with nihilistic qualities, unlike the protagonist beowulf, from the poem beowulf, who has an optimistic outlook on the world. It is a retelling of part of the old english poem beowulf from the perspective of.911 1280 593 932 323 227 660 897 1248 1223 927 1042 529 987 895 552 1650 1331 798 1504 853 220 552 312 444 630 1116 1134 1607 1246 683 1562 1323 132 276 22 428 1574 1208 1144 1331 466 585 32 173 558 1106 1309 115